View Single Post
  #27 (permalink)  
Old 08-21-2007, 08:41 PM
Shamus's Avatar
Shamus Shamus is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Ur-th
Posts: 303
Lightbulb Results of changing base resistance

Ok, first the results, then the analysis:

Code:
Value (ohms)  Measured  mA@12V  Notes
---------------------------------------------------------------------
680           678       230
820           818       210
1200          1184      170
1200+180      1363.6    150
1200+180+2.2  1366.6    150
1200+180+10   1374.3    150     Hung at 140 mA then stayed at 150 mA
1200+180+15   1379.4    150     Low resonance once spinning, spun up to high RPM; 120 mA with load
1200+180+22   1386.6    190     Weak resonance, low pitch, spun up to low RPM
1200+180+33   1397.1    190     Resonance, lower pitched, spun up to low RPM
1200+180+39   1403.3    190     Resonance, lower pitched, spun up to low RPM
1200+270      1452              Resonance, lower pitched, would not spin up
1200+390      1584              Resonance, lower pitched, would not spin up
1800          1784              370 mA resonance seen, went negative (!) amps, no resonance after that; would not spin up
2700          2680              Resonance, higher pitched, would not spin up
.
It was pretty surprising to find self-resonant behavior--I can see how people could get distracted by it. It's also easy to see why the coil resists the rotor in that mode, since the circuit no longer self-regulates at that point. The rotor would have to be turning at the resonant frequency to stay spinning!

My meter can only measure down two significant digits at these amperages, so I'm pretty sure there's some differentiation at those levels marked 150 mA. In particular, I'm thinking that 1374.3 ohm is probably closer to 150 mA than the other values.

I'm also finally seeing the 'shifting into high gear' phenomenon that you were talking about, Aaron, with the power consumption going down as the RPM goes up. It seems tuning is the key here.
Reply With Quote